def writ submi

8/10/2019 Def Writ Submi

1/9

DALAM MAHKAMAH TINGGI DI KUALA LUMPUR(BAHAGIAN DAGANG)

GUAMAN SIVIL NO. D6-22-1163-2008

ANTARA

ZALWADI FARMS (M) SDN BHD(dahulunya dikenali e!a"ai Inn#$ai Pe%&ai Sdn Bhd)(N#' Sya%ika *+,*-,.K) /PLAINTIF

DAN

0' PRUD1NT GAT1WA2 SDN BHD(N#' Sya%ika 33034*.5)

4' ALI BIN ARIFIN(N#' K6P -7+80-.+4.-487)

7' HARUN BIN HASHIM M9HD(N#' K6P 3,+*47.0+.-447) /D1F1NDAN

.D1F1NDAN

WRITTEN SUBMISSION OF THE DEFENDANTS IN OPPOSSING THEPLAINTIFFS SUMMONS IN CHAMBERS FOR SUMMARY UDGMENT

May i :leae 2#u% H#n#u%;

We a::end !el#< he De=endan>


2/9

4'0 ha he 0De=endan and he Plaini== had ene%ed in# a 7 %dPa%y

Se?ui%y a"%ee&en;


3/9

DEFENCE AND TRIABLE ISSUE

A THE 3RD

PARTY SECURITY AGREEMENT VIOLATES THE

4 MONEYLENDERS ACT 151 4! THE ACT #.

0'0 A??#%din" # e?i#n 7 #= he A? i:ulae ha .

[ moneylender means any person who lends a sum of

money to a borrower in consideration of a larger sum

being repaid to him]

[moneylending agreement means an agreement made

in writing between a moneylender and a borrower for the

repayment, in lumpsum or instalments, of money

borrowed by the borrower from the moneylender;]

[interest does not include any sum lawfully charged in

accordance with this Act by a moneylender for or on

account of stamp duties, fees payable by law and legal

costs but, save as aforesaid, includes any amount by

whatsoever name called in excess of the principal paid or

payable to a moneylender in consideration of or

otherwise in respect of a loan.]

(Please refer to the Defendants Bundle of Authorities

page 1-2)


4/9

0'4 Se?i#n 0- #= he A? i:ulae ha.

N# neylendin" a"%ee&en in %e:e? #= neylen

a=e% he ?#&in" in# =#%?e #= hi A? !y an unli?ened

neylende% hall !e en=#%?ea!le

0'7 The De=endan eek lea$e # %e=e% ke:ada A=ida$i Balaan

De=endan. De=endan


5/9

h' The De=endan %: $' $' /'& &=,,&%) $'% 7%%

')% ''('7% 7; $% P'((**'

4'- The Plani== had =ailed # h#<


6/9

4'* The i%%eii!le ?#n?lui#n u::#%in"

a==ida$i'

7' The De=endan in$ie he #u% # %e=e% # S%'&9,% S) B$) S;%)

I?$': S;%) S;%) S'%$ @200 8 CL 62; a ?ae de?ided :%i#% # he

?uu%en A?


7/9

B THE PLAINTIFF FAILED TO PROVE OR PROVIDE EVIDENCE THAT IT

HAS SUFFERED LOSS OR DAMAGES'

0' The Plaini== ha =ailed # h#< in he A=ida$i S#k#n"an Pe%a&a Plaini=

daed 4E'-'4++, and he A=ida$i S#k#n"an Kedua Plain= 4',4++, !y a?i#n #he% han !a%e a$e%&en in he u::#%in"

a==ida$i'

4' 1hi!i ZF.3 #= he A=ida$i S#k#n"an Pe%a&a Plaini=; a lee% =%#&

MBB add%eed # he 0De=endan #nly &eni#ned ha MBB


8/9

the Plaintifs docuentary evidence! suary

"udgent ought not #e given.

N# :%##= #= da&a"e # ?lai& =#% a"%eed liuidaed da&a"e'

-' The Plain== al# ?lai& =#% a"%eed liuidaed da&a"e a 8 :e% annu&

#n nhly %e #= he #uandin" !alan?e #alled RM 000;33+.++'

E' The :lain= ha =ailed # h#< :%##= #% e$iden?e #= h#< i ha u==e%ed

da&a"e' The :%#$ii#n #= e?i#n *- #= he #n%a? A? ?ann# !e

?#n%a?ed #u'

*' A??#%din" # $: C'&' D%%,% S) B$) C&:'';' S)

B$) @2005 CL 65; he Fede%al #u% a==i%& he :%in?i:le in Sel$a

Ku&a% Mu%u"aiah $ Thia%a@ah Renaa&y J0,,- 4 L 7*3 ha he

Plaini== &u :%#$e a?ual da&a"e #% %ea#na!le ?#&:enai#n in

a??#%dan?e


9/9

MAK UN 211N

Pe"ua& De=endan Kedua

ini di=ailkan #leh Teuan Teuan 2 Mak #; Pe"ua&!ela dan Pe"ua&?a%a !a"i

De=endan Kedua yan" !e%ala&a di N#'E7.4B; alan Me"a Mendun"; Bau-; 9== alan

Kelan" La&a; -84++ Kuala Lu&:u%J Tel Fa +7.*,84 8+,E 6 +0, 708 +*0-

(Ru@ M2'ASB'L.++E'4++-)

def writ submi

Documents