teddy mantoro - dosen perbanas · jenis publikasi karya ilmiah similarity score (plagiarism level)...

30
Teddy Mantoro [email protected]

Upload: vobao

Post on 25-Aug-2019

222 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

Teddy Mantoro

[email protected]

Page 2: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

No Jabatan Dosen

Dosen Tetap

2014

Dosen Tetap

2015

Dosen Tetap

2016

Jumlah % Jumlah % Jumlah %

1 GURU BESAR 369 2 371 1,8 250 1,3

2LEKTOR

KEPALA1736 9,4 1783 8,5 1375 6,9

3 LEKTOR 4333 23,5 4452 21,2 4239 21,2

4 ASISTEN AHLI 4188 22,7 4413 21 4695 23,5

5TENAGA

PENGAJAR7819 42,3 9958 47,5 9408 47,1

Jumlah 18445 20977 19967

source: PDdikti, 25/10/2016

Page 3: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

1. Jumlah Profesor Berkurang

2. Jumlah Lektor Kepala Berkurang

3. Jumlah Lektor Berkurang

4. Jumlah Asisten Ahli Bertambah

5. Jumlah Tenaga Pengajar Berkurang

Fakta Dalam Tiga Tahun Terakhir

Page 4: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

• Asisten Ahli = 629 orang

• Lektor = 295 orang

• Lektor Kepala = 106 orang

• Profesor = 11 orang

Peningkatan JabatanDosen

1041

• Beasiswa PT Dalam Negeri = 127 orang

• Beasiswa PT Luar Negeri = 17 orang

Peningkatan kualifikasi

akademik dosen ke S3

144

• Mutasi dosen = 330 orang

• Pemilihan Dosen Berprestasi = 5 orang

Pengembangan Karier

dan penghargaan

Dosen

335

Page 5: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

Pengindeks bereputasi Jenis Indeks dan faktor dampak (IF)

h-index dan g-index

Penelitian Ilmiah Mencari bidang yang akan diteliti

AI Method in Brief

Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah

Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level)

Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul

Abstract

Introduction, methodology, etc.

o Contoh penelitian dan hasilnya

Page 6: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

Menjelaskan tentang pengindeks bereputasi

Membedakan Jenis Indeks dan faktor dampak (IF)

Dapat menghitung h-index dan g-index

Dapat menetapkan area yang akan diteliti

Dapat menetapkan Idea pada suatu penelitian(Problem dan Solusi yang diusulkan)

Mampu menulis papers yang memiliki strong references dan rendah similarity-score-nya.

Mampu menghasilkan paper yang berpotensi di publikasi di jurnal Internasional bereputasi(Scopus dan WoS).

Page 7: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,
Page 8: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,
Page 9: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,
Page 10: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,
Page 11: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,
Page 12: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,
Page 13: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

Variables:

Author

Area – define by

author

Citations: All and the

last 5 years

h-Index

i10-index

Total papers

Page 14: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

Peneliti A

+++ reputable papers: journal atau conf ber-IF

--- first author atau corresponding author

---- bahasa Indonesia

Disiplin ilmu: Biologi

Citations=660

h-index = 14

I10-index=18

Peneliti B

--- reputable papers: journal atau conf ber-IF

+++ first author atau corresponding author

+++ bahasa Indonesia

Disiplin ilmu: Ilmu komputer

Citations=1176

h-index = 17

I10-index=35

Page 15: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

Peneliti A

h-index=12

Docs=26

Citations=390 from 322 docs

Peneliti B

h-index=0

Docs=1

Citations=0 from 0 docs

Page 16: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

Variables:

Author Id

ORCID

# docs

# Citations

# docs yg mengutip

h-Index

# co-authors

Subject area

Graph visualization

Page 17: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

Variables:

Jumlah Docs

Jumlah sitasi

Jumlah sitasi

tanpa self-citation

Citing-articles

tanpa self-citation

Rata-2 citation per

paper

h-index

Graph visualization

(ResearchID)

Page 18: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

The h-index is an author-level metric that attempts to measure both the

productivity and citation impact of the publications of a scientist or scholar.

Proposed by Jorge E. Hirsch (2005).

The index is a measure of the number of highly impactful papers a scientist has

published. The larger the number of important papers, the higher the h-index,

regardless of where the work was published.

To calculate it, only two pieces of information are required: the total number of

papers published (Np) and the number of citations (Nc) for each paper.

The h-index is defined by how many h of a researcher’s publications (Np) have at

least h citations each.

Source: http://www.benchfly.com/blog/h-index-what-it-is-and-how-to-find-yours/

Page 19: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

‘The index h, defined as the number of papers with citation

number greater than or equal to h, is a useful index to characterise the scientific output of aresearcher.’ (JE Hirsch)

The h-index is a measure of the number of publications

published (productivity) as well as how often they are cited

(impact).

PRODUCTIVITY + IMPACT = INFLUENCE

If your h-index is 15, you have 15 papers cited 15 times or more.

If your h-index is 20, you have 20 papers cited 20 times or more.

Page 20: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

Peneliti C Peneliti D

H Kutipan/Sitasi Kutipan/Sitasi

1 386 145

2 247 40

3 313 27

4 37 18

5 26 14

6 0 5

7 0 5

Total 1109 257

h-index’s weakness -- not consider:

• Type of author

• # papers

• # citations

• # span of time

Page 21: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

The G-index was proposed by Leo Egghe in his paper "Theory and

Practice of the G-Index" in 2006 as an improvement on the H-Index.

G-Index is calculated this way: "[Given a set of articles] ranked in

decreasing order of the number of citations that they received, the G-

Index is the (unique) largest number such that the top g articles received

(together) at least g^2 citations." (from Harzig's Publish or Perish Manual)

Advantages of the G-Index:

Accounts for the performance of author's top articles

Helps to make more apparent the difference between authors'

respective impacts. The inflated values of the G-Index help to give

credit to lowly-cited or non-cited papers while giving credit for highly-

cited papers.

Disadvantages of the G-Index:

Introduced in 2006 and debate continues whether G-Index is superior to

H-Index. Might not be as widely accepted as H-Index.

Page 22: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

g-index’s weakness -- not consider:

• Type of Author

• # papers

• # citations

• # span of time

Page 23: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

Peneliti C Peneliti DN Kutipan/Sitasi Kumulatif

Kutipan/Sitasi

N x N N Kutipan/Sitasi Kumulatif

Kutipan/Sitasi

N x N

1 386 386 1 1 145 145 1

2 247 633 4 2 40 185 4

3 313 946 9 3 27 212 9

4 37 983 16 4 18 230 16

5 26 1009 25 5 14 234 25

6 0 1009 36 6 5 239 36

7 0 1009 49 7 5 244 49

8 0 1009 64 8 1 245 64

9 0 1009 81 9 1 246 81

10 0 1009 100 10 1 247 100

11 0 1009 121 11 0 247 121

12 0 1009 144 12 0 247 144

13 0 1009 169 13 0 247 169

14 0 1009 196 14 0 247 196

15 0 1009 225 15 0 247 225

16 0 1009 256 16 0 247 256

17 0 1009 289 17 0 247 289

18 0 1009 324 18 0 247 324

19 0 1009 361 19 0 247 361

20 0 1009 400 20 0 247 400

21 0 1009 441 21 0 247 441

22 0 1009 484 22 0 247 484

23 0 1009 529 23 0 247 529

24 0 1009 576 24 0 247 576

25 0 1009 625 25 0 247 625

26 0 1009 676 26 0 247 676

27 0 1009 729 27 0 247 729

28 0 1009 784 28 0 247 784

29 0 1009 841 29 0 247 841

30 0 1009 900 30 0 247 900

31 0 1009 961 31 0 247 961

32 0 1009 1024 32 0 247 1024

33 0 1009 1089 33 0 247 1089

34 0 1009 1156 34 0 247 1156

h-index=5 g-index=31 h-index=5 g-index=15

Page 24: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,

Peneliti C Peneliti D

H Kutipan/Sitasi Kutipan/Sitasi

1 386 145

2 247 40

3 313 27

4 37 18

5 26 14

6 0 5

7 0 5

Total 1109 257

i10-index’s weakness -- not consider:

• Type of author

• # papers

• # citations

• # span of time

Page 25: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,
Page 26: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,
Page 27: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,
Page 28: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,
Page 29: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,
Page 30: Teddy Mantoro - Dosen Perbanas · Jenis Publikasi karya ilmiah Similarity Score (Plagiarism Level) Penulisan Proposal dan publikasi Ilmiah Judul Abstract Introduction, methodology,