stagnasi dan k em ajuan ma rxism e · pdf filepersyara t kan untuk pemua san/p em enuhan...
TRANSCRIPT
emsixraM naujameK nad isangatS
emsixraM naujameK nad isangatS
)3091( grubmexuL asoR
ni gnugeweB elaizos eiD ludujreb ,kiranem aynutkaw adap ipatet lakgnad gnay aynhamarec malaD neurG lraK ,)aigleB nad sicnareP id silaisoS nakareG( neigleB dnu hcierknarF ,nakataynem tapet araces
iroet awhab - tniaS nad reiruoF iroet - huragnep iaynupmem nomiS - sata adebreb tagnas gnay huragnepgnisam akerem tukignep arap - tniaS .gnisam - pakgnel isareneg utaus irad lautirips ruhulel halada nomiS
ip gnay silunep nad kidileynep arap tukignep arap ipatet ;lautkeletni sativitka gnadib iagabreb id iawagnaro ,nailaucegnep aparebeb nagned ,halada reiruoF - atak oebmem atubmem araces gnay gnaro - atak
nasalejneP .aynnaraja igab nup apa naujamek taubmem upmam kadit nad ,akerem urug/nipmimepurG gnay metsis utaus nagned ainud nakijaynem reiruoF awhab ,halada ini naadebrep ianegnem ne
satnut - tniaS nakgnades ;aynnaicnir aumes malad nakiaruid ,idaj - sakrebes nakrapmelem amuc nomiS -narikip sapel - neurG ukigab nupilakeS .ayndirum arap adap raseb narikip ulalret nakirebmem aynkaga
iroet aratna id rasadnem naadebrep ,lanretni naadebrep adap naitahrep tikides - satiroto audek iroet tapet uti natamagnep aynnahurulesek malad awhab asarem uka ,ini naipotu emsilaisos gnadib id kisalk
gal nakisgnaynem kadiT .aynada nasagag metsis haubes ,i - sirag malad nakrabmagid aynah gnay nasagag - gnay sirtemis nad iaseles gnay rutkurts haubes adapirad gnasgnarem hibel huaj itkubret aynraseb sirag
asu igab )epocs( nasawalek utaus nakrawanem kadit nad nupapa nahabmat nakulremem kadit sabeb ah.fitka gnay narikip utaus
naikes amales nakgnanacid halet gnay ,emsixraM nirtkod malad isangats nakbabeynem gnay ini hakapAhalada aynlautka naatayneK ?nuhat kaynab - gnay sabeb isubirtnok aud uata utas ilaucek ,awhab
naroes naujamek utaus iadnanem )iroet ilha( naisiteroet g - nad ladoM rihakaret emulov isakilbup kajesnasilut irad rihkaret gnay - isasirelupop aparebeb adapirad hibel gnay nupapa tibret adait ,slegnE nasilut
iagabes patet uti iroet isnatsbuS .sixraM iroet ianegnem sugab gnay narapamep nad gnay anam.uti haimli emsilaisos iridnep audek helo naklaggnitid
akgnarek haubes ukak ulalret araces nakanegnem halet sixraM metsis nakanerakid ini hakapA - sata ajreksativitka - ?nednepedni narikip sativitka
iaynupmem halet xraM awhab lakgnasid tapad kadiT nagnabmegnep isatabmem gnay huragnep utausdirum helo sabeb araces iroet - kalonem kutnu ulrep paggnagnem slegnE nupuam xraM .ayndirum
gnuggnatreb - napacu sata bawaj - gnay ahasU !sixraM aynirid tubeynem gnay akerem irad kaynab napacub malad patet raga amaskes sata - satirgetni igab aynakalec amas nikgnum alakgnadak emsixraM satab
aynnial mertske itrepes rikipreb sesorp - daket nad ,sixraM nagnadnap padahret aynhunepes nakalonep.aynokiser alages iludep apnat narikip nasabebek nakisatsefinamem kutnu
utigeb nupualaW halasam tukgnaynem gnay aynah , - gnatnet aracibreb kahreb atik imonoke halasamgnatab utaus - nirtkod hubut - gnaruk gnay nirtkod - xraM helo naksirawid gnay pakgnel araces iaruret hibel
naraja aumes irad agrahreb gnilap gnaY .atik adap - iretam ispesnok ,aynnaraja sila - gnatnet kitkelaid aparebeb iagabes ,nakidileynep edotem haubes adapirad hibel kadit iagabes atik igab ridah ,harajes
nasalik nakrawanem gnay ,imahlignem gnay naharagnep narikip - malad ek atik adap nagnadnap nasalikamas gnay ainud utaus - ay ,urab ilakes fitkepsrep atik adap nakakubmem gn - adait gnay fitkepsrep
nagnabrenep igab atik tagnames ipayaynem gnay ,nednepedni sativitka ianegnem aynsatab -hayaliw malad ek inareb gnay nagnabrenep - .isarolpskeid muleb gnay hayaliw
ini hayaliw id nakhab ,utigeb nupualaW lakgnad hisam sixraM nasiraw ,nailaucek aparebeb nagned , emsilairetam ianegnem iroet nad ;iakapid adait anerak tarakreb uti hupma gnay urab atajneS .aynada
sirag radekes nad pakgnel araces nakiaruret kadit patet sirotsih - itek itrepes )yhcteks( raseb sirag ak.aynatpicnep arap helo naksumurid ilak amatrep
nasalejnep idajnem uti sixraM nanugnab napakgnelek nad naukakek awhab nakatakid tapad kadit ,akaM.uti nanugnab naktujnalem kutnu xraM surenep arap aynlagag ianegnem
tik nakareg awhab uhatirebid gnires atiK gnaro ikilimem kadit a - nikgnum gnay takabreb gnaroiroet tujnal hibel nakiarugnem kutnu naupmamekreb - ,gnamem ,uti itrepes nagnarukeK .xraM iroet
tapad kadit nad ,nasalejnep utaus tutnunem iridnes uti nagnarukek ipatet ;amal kajes ada hadusutnu nakakumekid nuruk paites awhab tagni itsem atiK .aynkokop naaynatrep bawajnem k - namaj
nahutubek utaus tapadret edoirep utauses id alibapa ,awhab ;iridnes aynaisunam lairetam kutnebmemnenopske naka itajes - nataukek nakatpicnem naka uti edoirep akam ,sitiroet nenopske -k id gnay natauke
.uti nahutubek nahunemep/nasaumep kutnu naktaraysrep
huggnus nahutubek utaus hakada ,ipateT - hibel nagnabmekrep igab ,fitkefe natutnut utaus ,huggnus?sixraM iroet irad tujnal
narajA aratna isrevortnok ianegnem nagnarak haubes ,malaD - araja ,sirggnI id naisnoveJ nad sixraM nimes irad takabreb nenopske ,wahS dranreB - halet anerak namdnyH kejegnem ,naibaF emsilaisos
naka pakgnel namahamep utaus aynadap nakirebmem halet ladoM amatrep emulov awhab nakatagnemhalec tapadret adait awhab nad ,xraM -c sixraM iroet malad )spag( hale - id ,slergnE hcirdeirF nupilakes
ayniroet nagned amatrep emulov awhab nakataynem naidumek ,ladoM audek emulov atakarp malad gnay ,latnemadnuf gnay imonoke halasam utaus nakhacepret kadit nakraibmem halet ,ialin gnatnet
hacemep taubmem lisahreb salej wahS .nakmumuid agitek emulov mulebes nakirebid naka kadit aynna nagned irid rubihgnem ajas asib namdnyH nupualaw ,ilakes nakawatrenem kapmat namdnyH isisop
gnay uharep malad adareb silaisos ainud hurules atakid helob awhab naataynek !amas
arap irad rasad halasam( abal takgnit ianegnem halasam nahacemep nagned ,ladoM irad agitek emuloV iregen aumes id itrepes ,namreJ id aynlah itrepeS .4981 nuhat mulebes tibret kadit ,)sixraM imonoke ilha
nautnab nagned nakukalid halet isatiga ,nial malad id gnudnakid gnay iaseles muleb gnay lairetam nakrasadreb naamirenep naktapadnem nad isasirelupopid halet sixraM nirtkod ;amatrep emulov ;lanemonef tagnas gnamem uti pakgnel kadit gnay sixraM iroet nalisahrebek ;ajas ini amatrep emulov
roes kadit nad .uti naraja malad id halec utauses tapadret awhab iradaynem nupgna
id naitahrep kiranem ai aynlawa adap aratnemes ,tibret aynrihka agitek emulov akitek ,ayntujnaleSnagnalak - utnetret ratnemok halmujes naklubminem nad ,satabret gnay ilha arap nagnalak - ajes gnay hu
igab naknasegnem kadit atakid helob uti urab emulov ,nahurulesek araces silaisos nakareg ianegnemhayaliw - nasagag anam id saul hayaliw - .nanimod idajnem halet uti ilsa ukub malad sahabid uti nasagag
it inik aggnih 3 emulov irad lakiteroet nalupmiseK ,isasirelupop hara ek nupapa ahasu naklubminem kadrabeynep nimajnem kadit aguj akerem - tarcomed laicos muak nagnalak id nakhab ,aynkilabeS .nasaul
naameggnep ,ini asawed ,ragnednem atik alakgnadak - ladoM agitek emulov nagned naawecekek ilabmeks utigeb gnay siujrub imonoke ilha arap helo nakarausid gnire - laisos muak naikimed nagned nad
kadit narapamep amirenem akerem aynhunepes apateb naktahilrepmem radekes amuc ini tarkomed)*.amatrep emulov malad nakijasid gnay ialin gnatnet iroet pakgnel
ad atik anamiagaB raul naikimed gnay alajeg utaus nakgnarenem tap - nagned( gnay ,wahS ?asaibgnaro nakawatrenem akus )iridnes aynnapakgnu pitugnem - id nasalareb tagnas ajas nikgnum ,nial gnaro
!xraM adap nakrasadid uti huajes ,silaisos nakareg hurules nakawatrenem kutnu ,inis ini ualak ,ipateT laicos napudihek irad tawag/suires tagnas gnay isatsefinam nakawatrenem naka ai ,aynnakukalid gnay irad nakutnenem gnilap itkub nakapurem ladoM irad agitek nad audek emulov irad lijnag bisaN .atik
nakareg lakiteroet naitilenep mumu bisan .atik
tudus iraD - iagabes gnadnapid amaturet ,ilakes salej ,itsem ladoM irad agitek emulov ,haimli gnadnap mukuh kiab ,itregnem tapad kadit atik ini agitek emulov apnaT.emsilatipak sata xraM kitirk napakgnelep
raneb gnay abal takgnit ianegnem - animod raneb ialin aynhacep nupuam ;n - agnub ,abal idajnem hibel gnay halasam ini nad ,ipateT ,nagniasrep gnadib malad id ialin mukuh aynajrekeb uata ;awes nad malad ,ayninrumes iroet gnadnap tudus irad ayngnitnep nupapateb ,ini halasam aumes ,amaturet
lada nagnidnabrep ianegnem gnay huajeS .salek gnarep irad sitkarp gnadnap tudus irad gnitnep kadit halasa halada latnemadnuf gnay sitiroet halasam ,salek gnarep - haimli nasalejnep ,utiay ,hibel ialin lusu
agnurednecek ianegnem nasalejnep nagned amasreb ;isatiolpske ianegnem n- adap nagnurednecek.silaisos isulover fitkejbo nasadnal ianegnem haimli nasalejnep ,utiay ,iskudorp sesorp isasilaisos
nasapmarep iskudednem gnay ,ladoM amatrep emulov malad id nakhacepid halet ini halasam audeKdit tabika iagabes sapmarep muak padahret ialin iskudorp nahadusek nad nakkaleret ka - irad nad hibel
nakareg kokop nahutubek ,iroet ianegnem gnay huajes ,uti nagneD .ladom irad fisergorp isartnesnokiaynupmem kadit ,salk )nagnaujrep( gnarep malad id fitka tabilret gnay ,hurub muaK .ihunepid ajrekep
ialin anamiagab nalaosrep malad gnusgnal nagnitnepek - gnisam nagnalak id nakisubirtsidid hibel - gnisam nagniasrep ,ini isubirtsid sesorp malad id ,anamiagab nalaosrep malad uata ;pasihgnep kopmolek
naatanep naklubminem - .iskudorp ilabmek
nem aynbabes halutI nakapurem patet ladoM agitek emulov ,aynmumu adap silaisos muak igab ,apagnirtkod igab ukalreb gnay ,atik nakareg malad id ,ipateT .acabret kadit ukub haubes - imonoke nirtkod
u ayninrumes isuli nakapureM .aynmumu sitiroet naitilenep igab alup ukalreb ,xraM paggnagnem kutnkat idajnem iridnes naupmamek sata tapad ,ayngnasap nakareg malad id ,ajrekep salk awhab - aggnihret
gnay ajas hurub muak ,slegnE helo nakatakid itrepes ,awhab raneB .sitiroet hayaliw malad id aynfitaerk namahamep utaus arahilemem ini asawed naka hurub muak tarsaH .iroet malad nagnitnepek nad naka
umli - halas nakapurem nauhategnep - .ini asawed kolocnem gnilap gnay larutluk isatsefinam irad utassalk nagnaujrep ,aguj ,larom araceS - isapisitrap ipateT .takaraysam larutluk isavoner iadnanem ajrekep
pared malad id hurub muak fitka - isidnok nahunemep adap gnutnagreb tagnas umli ujam - laisos isidnok.utnetret
helo nakatpicid )nailhaek nad nauhategnep umli( lautkeletni rutluk ,salekreb takaraysam paites malaDlada ini rutluk naujut nad ;asaukreb gnay salk gnusgnal nasaumep nimajnem kutnu naigabes ha
nahutubek - nahutubek naksaumem kutnu igal naigabes nad ,laisos sesorp nahutubek - latnem nahutubek.hatniremem gnay salk atoggna arap
nagnaujrep harajes malaD - salk ,aynmulebes salek nagnaujrep - isaripsareb gnay salk nagnoloG itrepes(urab asam agiteK - isanimod utaus nakkagenem nagned kitilop naasaukek isapisitnagnem tapad )ini urab
huajes ,lautkeletni - salk nakapurem hisam akerem aratnemes - akkudnutid gnay salk -- tapad akerem nailhaek utaus nad urab umli utaus nugnabmem namaj nalaggnitek hadus gnay rutluk padahret urab
.uti nedaked edoirep irad
kadit gnay salk utaus iagabeS .adebreb tagnas gnay nakududek utaus malad adareb tairatelorP - ,kilimrebs nakatpicnem natnops araces nagnaujrep ayngnasap sesorp malad tapad kadit ai latnem rutluk utau
,uti takaraysam malad iD .siujrub takaraysam akgnarek malad adareb patet ai aratnemes ,iridnes akeremnasadnal amales nad - rutluk utaus ilaucek nial rutluk ada asib kadit ,hukukisreb aynimonoke nasadnal
os roseforp arap nupilakeS .siujrub naanuggnep ,isad naanegnep ikaroynem nikgnum utnetret silaisutrak - hotnoc iagabes ratelorp muak helo adepes iaradnegnem nad ,aman utrak - tutap gnay hotnoc
id adareb patet iridnes uti ajrekep muak ,larutluk naujamek malad isapuisitrap ianegnem nakitahrepidl nagnat nagned hurub muak awhab naataynek aynada nupualaW .reropmetnok/namajes rutluk rau
naknanekrepid aynah akerem ,ini rutluk irad laisos mutartsbus hurules nakatpicnem iridnes akerem ajrenik kutnu naktaraysrepid uti itrepes nanekrep huajes aynitamkinem isgnuf irad naksaumem gnay -
.silatipak takaraysam irad laisos nad imonoke sesorp malad id akerem isgnuf
iridnes aynnailhaek utaus nakatpicnem kutnu isisiop utaus malad id adareb naka kadit ajrekep salKk isisop irad isapisnamereb aynhunepes halet ai iapmas gnilaP .gnarakes gnay aynsal - tapad gnay gnilap
nad ,siujrub iskaer emsiladnav padahret siujrub rutluk naknamagnem halada ini asawed aynnakukalidisidnok nakatpicnem - .sabeb gnay larutluk nagnabmekrep utaus igab nakulrepid gnay laisos isidnok
ajnapes nakhaB sirag gn - tapad aynah ,ukalreb gnay takaraysam kutneb malad id ,hurub muak ,ini siragakerem huajes ujam - iridnes akerem irid igab - atajnes nakatpicnem tapad - gnay lautkeletni atajnes
.nasabebmep kutnu akerem nagnaujrep malad nakulrepid
nagnadacnep ipateT - nep nanipmip arap adap ,utiay( ajrekep salk adap nakaskamem ini nagnadacnasatab )hurub muak lautkeletni - nataigek gnadib id tipmes tagnas gnay nasatab - .lautkeletni nataigek
umli nemetraped utas adap isatabid akerem fitaerk ijrene hayaliW - usuhk gnay nauhategnep umli utiay ,s )etatsE htruoF( tapmeeK nagnoloG nasagag irad sahk natiak takreb huajes ,aneraK .laisos nauhategnep
mukuh tukgnaynem gnay naharecnep ,atik sirotsih nuruk nagned - halet laisos nagnabmekrep mukuhnaujrep malad id hurub muak igab laisnese idajnem nagned nakhaubmem halet ini natiakretek ,salk nag
:gnarakes atik namaj nairatelorp rutluk irad nemunom nad.laisos nauhategnep umli malad ilakes kiab.sixraM nirtkod
lem ,asaskar nahutuek utaus nakapurem haimli ayrak utaus iagabes gnay ,xraM naatpic ipateT iuapmanatutnut - malad id kiaB .nakatpicid ai aynkutnu gnay ratelorp salek nagnaujrep irad anahredes natutnut
pakgnel nad icniret gnay aynsisilana - edotem malad id nupuam ,silatipak imonoke ianegnem huruleynemaynnaparenep nadem nagned aynsirotsih naitilenep huaj nakrawanem halet xraM ,aggnihret adait gnay
.uti salk )nagnaujrep( gnarep sitkarp ukalirp igab laisnese gnusgnal araces gnay adapirad kaynab hibelparedreb nagned nagnabmiesek malad aynaH - nahacemep tutnunem nad ,atik nakareg aynujam
nalaosrep - laosrep ilakes atik ,urab sitkarp na - raga ,xraM narikimep naayakek malad ek abminem igalnemgarf nakanuggnem nad abminem aynirad - ,atik nakareg anerak ipateT.aynnirtkod irad urab nemgarf
malad suret ajrekeb kutnu gnurednec ,sitkarp napudihek eynapmak aumes itrepes rula - narikip rula
saza adap tuyagreb nad ,amal - saza haletes saza - akam ,aynnahihasek malad itnehreb uti saza.tabmal tagnas nagned nalajreb uti sixraM metsis siteroet naanuggnep
atik nakareg malad id isangats utaus isketednem atik ini asawed alibapa ,akaM ianegnem gnay huajeshalasam - upmam kadit uti atik ipudihgnem gnay sixraM iroet anerak halnakub ini ,ini sitiroet halasam
nalaggnitek idajnem halet uata gnabmekreb - rajaleb muleb atik anerak halada ,aynkilabeS .namajs gnay naanuggnep utaus taubmem anamiagab atajnes irad nadape - gnitnep gnilap gnay latnem atajnes
atajnes naka atik kasednem nahutubek nakrasadreb sixraM atajnes gnadug irad nakraulek halet gnay -pahat malad id uti atajnes - tukgnaynem gnay huajes ,awhab raneb halkadiT .atik nagnaujrep inid pahat
jrep .xraM gnaubmem/nakitnaggnem halet atik awhab ,namaj nalaggnitek hadus xraM ,sitkarp nagnaugnaujep iatrap utaus iagabes atik iuapmalem halet ,aynhaimli naatpic malad id ,xraM ,aynkilabeS -
bek igab ipukucnem igal kadit xraM awhab raneb kadiT .sitkarp gnaujep nahutu - .atik nahutubeknahutubek ,aynkilabeS - nasagag naanuggnep igab nadapes muleb hisam atik nahutubek - .xraM nasagag
isidnok nagned aynada halnaikimeD - takaraysam malad id nairatelorp naadarebek irad laisos isidnokasam - isidnok ,inik - amatrep gnay isidnok nagned madned salabmem ,sixraM iroet helo naksalejid ilak
tala utaus nakapurem uti iroet nupualaW .iridnes uti sixraM iroet sata nakaskap akerem gnay bisan asib kadit ai aratnemes ,anerak iakapret kadit patet ai ,aynnagnidnab adait gnay lautkeletni rutluk
nahutubek iuapmalem tagnas ai ,siujrub salk rutluk adap nakparetid - malad id ajrekep salk nahutubekirahes nagnaujrep igab naatajnesrep nalaosrep - isidnok irad naksabebid ajrekep salk mulebes kadiT .irah -
naitilenep edotem ,gnarakes gnay aynnaadarebek isidnok naiakgnareb nakisasilaisosret naka uti sixraMarac nagned - nagnutnuek imed nakanugrepid aynhunepes tapad ai aggnihes ,aynnial iskudorp arac
hunepes aggnih nakgnabmekid tapad ai naikimed nagned nad ,aynhurules naaisunamek - aynhunepnoisgnuf satisapak turunem .aynla
natataC
,metsyS tsilatipaC eht fo nwodkaerB eht dna noitalumuccA fo waL ehT :nnamssorG ayrak haubeS )* fo etar eht fo llaf eht( abal takgnit gnatnet iroet ianegnem susuhk sahabmem ,0391 nuhat natibret
purem gnamem gnay )abal takgnit aynhutaJ/tiforp .emsilatipak metsis nad ialin gnatnet iroet itni naka