krisisfelda - c4 center diperah... · 2018. 4. 10. · krisisfelda...

16

Upload: others

Post on 10-Feb-2021

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • KRISIS FELDASemasa Felda ditubuhkan pada tahun 1956 untuk membasmikemiskinan yang menular melalui program pertanian dankemajuan tanah, tiada siapa menjangka yang agensi ini akanmenjadi sebuah kejayaan yang luar biasa.Felda telah menempatkan semula 122,635 buah keluarga1 danmengeluarkan kira-kira 1 juta orang dari kemiskinan, suatupencapaian yang dipuji oleh Bank Dunia sebagai salah satuprogram kemajuan tanah yang paling berjaya di dunia.2

    Namun, Felda kini terjerumus dalam beberapa kontroversikorporat. Bagaimanakah institusi ini boleh terjerat dalampermasalahan rasuah yang serius? Siapa yangbertanggungjawab di atas krisis dalam Felda?

    TheCenter toCombatCorruption andCronyism(C4Center)adalahsebuahpusatadvokasi dasar kerajaanbukanuntungyangbertujuanuntukmemerangi rasuah,kronismedanmasalahberkaitandi semuaperingkat kerajaan.Alamat: A-3-7A-3-7,8Avenue, JalanSungai Jernih8/1,Seksyen8,

    46050Petaling Jaya,Malaysia.Tel: +60379322507

    LamanWeb: www.c4center.orgEmel: [email protected]

    https://www.c4center.org

  • Kontroversi KLVC MendedahkanPermasalahan

    KONTROVERSI-KONTROVERSI

  • Politik dalam Lembaga

    2005 2009 2011

  • PenyenaraianMenyebabkanKerugian Kepada Umum

    Pembelian Lain yang Bermasalah

  • Dari Birokrat ke Ahli Politik

    PERALIHAN KUASA DAN KESANNYA

  • Pemusatan Kuasa Membawakepada Penyelewengan

  • PERSOALAN YANG MASIH BERLEGAR DANLANGKAH SETERUSNYA

  • 1 LaporanTahunanFelda 2016.2 KhorYuLengetal,HighCarbonStockConsultingStudy

    12:TheFeldaCaseStudy,Oxford,LMC InternationalLtd. (2015).

    3 New StraitsTimes,Felda land inJalanSemarakworthmore in themarket, 23Disember 2017,https://www.nst.com.my/news/nation/2017/12/317541/feldalandjalansemarakworthmoremarket, diaksespada5April 2018.

    4 TheStar Online,Feldawants landownershipback, 22Disember 2017,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2017/12/22/feldawantslandownershipbackcivilactionagainstcompanyinvolvedintransferispossiblesayss/,diaksespada23Januari 2018.

    5 MalayMailOnline,Shadow castover ID company inFelda land transfer, 27Disember 2017,http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/shadowcastoveridcompanyinfeldalandtransfer,diaksespada5April 2018.

    6 Hasil cariansyarikat yangdijalankandenganSuruhanjayaSyarikatMalaysiapada22Dis.2017.

    7 TheBorneoPost,Zakat concept cannarrow social gap,strengthenMuslimhub, saysNajib, 27Jun2016,http://www.theborneopost.com/2016/06/27/zakatconceptcannarrowsocialgapstrengthenmuslimhubsaysnajib/, diaksespada23Mac2018.

    8 TheStar Online,Samsudin:Feldaboardnot informedoftransfer ofownership, 27Disember 2017,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2017/12/27/samsudinfeldaboardnotinformedoftransferofownership/, diaksespada18Januari 2018;TheStarOnline,Clarify full power ofattorneygiven tocompany,28Disember 2017,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2017/12/28/clarifyfullpowerofattorneygiventocompany/, diaksespada18Januari 2018.

    9 MalayMailOnline, IsaSamadsigned legal transferdocument for FeldaJalanSemarak,Parliament told, 12

    Mac2018,http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/isasamadsignedlegaltransferdocumentforfeldajalansemarakparliament#S5fLhTJx6jZOmY4t.97,diaksespada16Mac2018.

    10 MalayMailOnline,Felda regainedpossessionof JalanSemarak land, chairmanconfirms, 9Mac2018,http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/feldaregainedpossessionsofjalansemaraklandchairmanconfirms#kqeohGXft5yu6rdA.97,diaksespada16Mac2018.

    11 Malaysiakini, IsaSamad’sappointment ‘badnews formarket’, 8Februari 2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/155488,diaksespada13Mac2018;Malaysiakini,Feldachief IsaSamadunfazedbycritics, 9Februari 2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/155630,diaksespada13Mac2018.

    12 TheStar Online, Isasuspendedafter being foundguiltyofmoneypolitics, 25Jun2005,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2005/06/25/isasuspendedafterbeingfoundguiltyofmoneypolitics/,diaksespada1Mac2018.

    13 TheStar Online, Isa’s suspensionover moneypoliticsends, 24Jun2008,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2008/06/24/isassuspensionovermoneypoliticsends/, diaksespada9Mac2018.;Malaysiakini, IsaSamadCalonBN diBaganPinang, 29September 2009,https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/113847,diaksespada9Mac2018.

    14 Malaysiakini,Felda’sRM6bil listing tobecountry’s thirdlargest, 24Oktober 2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/179573,diaksespada16Mac2018;Malaysiakini,Feldasettlers told to ignorepoisonpen letters, 10Disember 2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/183790,diaksespada16Mac2018.

    15 TheStar Online,KLSE listing for Felda, 13September2003,

    NOTA

  • https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2003/09/13/klselistingforfelda/, diaksespada24Januari 2018.

    16 TheStar Online,Minister:Felda’sKLSE listingwillbenefit settlers, 15September 2003,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2003/09/15/ministerfeldasklselistingwillbenefitsettlers/, diaksespada24Januari 2018.;RashilaRamli,TheMultipleRolesofRuralMalayWomenduring the1999Election:TheCaseofFeldaJ8, published inNew Politics inMalaysia, InstituteofSoutheastAsianStudies,Singapore, (2003).

    17 TheStar Online,ListingofFeldaHoldingsputonhold, 6November 2003,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2003/11/06/listingoffeldaholdingsputonhold/, diaksespada23Januari 2018.

    18 Malaysiakini, Isa:Settlershaveno reason to reject listing,20Disember 2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/184610,diaksespada16Mac2018;Malaysiakini,FGVH togoaheadwith IPOwithoutKPF, says Isa,25April 2012,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/196009,diaksespada16Mac2018.;Malaysiakini,300settlersprotestresistance toFelda listing, 18Disember 2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/184460,diaksespada16Mac2018;Malaysiakini,NGO slams Isaover FeldaGlobal listing, 21Disember 2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/184742, diaksespada16Mac2018;Malaysiakini,NGO seeks injunctionagainstFeldaGlobal listing, 23Disember 2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/184852,diaksespada16Mac2018.

    19 Malaysiakini,Anak:RetainFeldaDG and remove IsaSamad, 13Disember 2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/184016,diaksespada16Mac2018;Malaysiakini,PKR:NajibmustexplanFeldaDG’s ‘study leave’, 14Disember 2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/184109,diaksespada16Mac2018;Malaysiakini,Perkasa leads1,000 inprotestagainstFeldaDG, 15Disember 2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/184206, diaksespada16Mac2018;Malaysiakini,FeldaDG axed, coldstoraged inRome, 29Ogos2012,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/207365,diaksespada16Mac2012;Malaysiakini,Anak refutes Isa’sclaimonFeldaDG’s removal, 4September 2012,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/207949,diaksespada16Mac2018.

    20 Seksyen23(1)AktaKemajuanTanah195621 SetakatDisember 2016,Feldamemegang33.67%

    sahamdalamFGV danKPF memegang5.5%daham

    dalamFGV.22 TheStar,Fraud inFeldaGlobalVentures,23November

    2016,https://www.thestar.com.my/business/businessnews/2016/11/23/fraudinfgv/, diaksespada5April2018.

    23 TheStar Online,Report:SafitexTradingOwesFGV unitRM50m, 8 Jun2017,http://m.thestar.com.my/story.aspx?hl=ReportSafitexTradingowesFGVunitRM50m&sec=business&id=%7B3293B28D8DF047DD83E1B41172512FB7%7D, diaksespada5April2018.

    24 TheMalaysian Insight,Seriesofbaddecisions led toFGV’sRM13.4billionsharewipeout, 10Jun2017,https://www.themalaysianinsight.com/s/4753/, diaksespada30Mac2018.

    25 TheStar Online,FGV suspendsgrouppresidentandCFO, 6 Jun2017,https://www.thestar.com.my/business/businessnews/2017/06/06/fgvzakariaarshadsuspended/,diaksespada22Januari 2018.;TheStar Online,FGV’sZakariasayshedisagreedwithseveral investments, 6Jun2017,https://www.thestar.com.my/business/businessnews/2017/06/06/fgvzakariasayshedisagreedwithseveralinvestments/, diaksespada22Januari 2018;TheStar Online,AsFGV showdown looms,CEO laysdownultimatum– itseither himor Isa, 7 Jun2017,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2017/06/07/decisioninhandsofshareholdersasfgvshowdownloomsceolaysdownultimatumitseitherhimori/,diaksespada22Januari 2018.

    26 TheMalayMailOnline,PMO defendsFelda’sRM500mLondonhotel foray, sayswill bringyield, 21Oktober2013,http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/pmodefendsfeldasrm500mlondonhotelforaysayswillbringyield#MyyEBWvGJPV3lRML.99,diaksespada5Januari 2018;TheMalayMailOnline,JustifyFelda’soverpricedLondonhotel foray,GuanEng tellsPutrajaya,23Oktober 2013,http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/justifyfeldasoverpricedlondonhotelforayguanengtellsputrajaya#JDfd6hdOEgkL6fk9.99,diaksespada5Januari 2018;TheMalayMailOnline,Noteverything isracial,GuanEng tellsUMNO’sZainuddin, 11November2013,http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/noteverythingisracialguanengtellsumnoszainuddin#hJFfCxWpfOXdmXT2.99,diaksespada5Januari 2018.

  • 27 TheMalayMailOnline,MACC saysprobingFeldaInvestmentCorp for overpricedLondonhotel buy, 14Julai 2017,http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/maccsaysprobingfeldainvestmentcorpforoverpricedlondonhotelbuy#BFOl8Q3dgc4FsuDw.97,diaksespada5Januari 2018 ;TheStar Online,MACC probingFIC’spurchaseofhighendLondonproperty, 14Julai2017,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2017/07/14/maccprobingficspurchaseofhighendlondonproperty/, diaksespada5Januari 2018.

    28 New StraitsTimes,FIC probepromptedbyhotel’sprice,29Julai 2017,https://www.nst.com.my/news/nation/2017/07/261868/ficprobepromptedhotelsprice,diaksespada4April2018; New StraitsTimes,MACC smellsa rat inanotherFIC hotel deal, 18Ogos2017,https://www.nst.com.my/news/exclusive/2017/08/269252/maccsmellsratanotherfichoteldeal, diaksespada30Mac2018.

    29 Malaysiakini,Shahrir: FeldaputsLondonpropertyup forsale, 12Oktober 2017,https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/398164#j0hcRquoHAVr3J5e.99,diaksespada5Januari 2018;TheMalayMailOnline,Felda jual sahamMaybank, hotelRM1biliondiLondon,17Januari 2017,http://www.themalaymailonline.com/projekmmo/berita/article/feldamahujualsahammaybankhotelrm1biliondilondon#SzR3Ex435pkmywWP.97,diaksespada5Januari 2018.

    30 TheStar Online,Feldaclarifiesacquisitionof IndonesianEagleHighstake, 2 Januari 2017,https://www.thestar.com.my/business/businessnews/2017/01/02/feldaclarifiesacquisitionofeaglehighstake/, diaksespada25Mac2018.

    31 JakartaGlobe,150Richest Indonesian, 1 Julai 2016,http://jakartaglobe.id/uncategorized/petersondakh64/,diaksespada3April 2018;FinancialTimes,Palmoildealembroiled inMalaysianpolitics,30Disember 2016,https://www.ft.com/content/44e04f0accd611e6864f20dcb35cede2,diaksespada3April 2018.

    32 TheEdgeMarket,Cover story:Peter Sondakh– themastermindbehindEagleHigh, 12Januari 2017,http://www.theedgemarkets.com/article/coverstorypetersondakh%E2%80%94mastermindbehindeaglehigh,diaksespada23Mac2018.

    33 MalaysiaToday,1MDB:All eyesonNajib’sbuddyPeterSondakh, 14Jun2015,http://www.theedgemarkets.com/article/coverstorypetersondakh%E2%80%94mastermindbehind

    eaglehigh,diaksespada23Mac2018;TheJakartaPost,MalaysiaFeldaacquires37percentofRajawali’sEagleHigh, 20April 2017,http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2017/04/20/malaysianfeldaacquires37percentofrajawaliseaglehigh.html, diaksespada25Mac2018.

    34 TheGuardian,1MDB:The insidestoryof theworld’sbiggest financial scandal, 28Julai 2016,https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jul/28/1mdbinsidestoryworldsbiggestfinancialscandalmalaysia,diaksespada3April 2018.

    35 Pada2016, JabatanKeadilanAmerikaSyarikat (DOJ)telahmemfailkanguamandiMahkamahuntukmenyitaasetaset yangdibelimenggunakanwangyangdicuridari 1MDB.Tindakan tersebutadalahyangpalingbesaryangpernahdifailkanolehDOJdibawah ‘KleptocracyAssetRecovery Initiative’.Tindakankedua telahdifailkanoadaJulai 2017.Salinankenyataan rasmiDOJdandokumenmahkamahyangberkaitanbolehdicapaidi sini: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/unitedstatesseeksrecovermore1billionobtainedcorruptioninvolvingmalaysiansovereigndanhttps://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/usseeksrecoverapproximately540millionobtainedcorruptioninvolvingmalaysiansovereign

    36 TheStar Online,FGV grilled for sixhours, shareholdersscrutinise fallingprofit, 17Jun2017,https://www.thestar.com.my/business/businessnews/2015/06/17/fgvgrilledforsixhours/, diaksespada23Januari 2018

    37 KWSPtelahmenjualkankesemuasahamnyadidalamFGV.New StraitsTimes,EPF hassoldall its shares inFGV, 22Disember 2016,https://www.nst.com.my/news/2016/12/198772/epfhassoldallitssharesfgv,diaksespada18Mac2018.

    38 TheEdgeMarket,AllFeldaGlobalVentures investorsshouldoppose Indonesiandeal, saysDAP, 18Jun2015,http://www.theedgemarkets.com/article/allfeldaglobalventuresinvestorsshouldopposeindonesiandealsaysdap,diaksespada18Mac2018.

    39 InternationalPalmOilMonitor,Something rotten inFelda’sdealingswithEagleHigh, 31May2017,http://ipom.global/2017/05/31/somethingrotteninfeldasdealingswitheaglehigh/, diaksespada25Mac2018.

    40 TheEdgeMarket,Leaked report castsdoubtonEagleHigh’svaluation, 26Jun2017,http://www.theedgemarkets.com/article/leakedreportcastsdoubteaglehighsvaluation,diaksespada30Mac2018.

    41 TheEdgeSingapore,Nosynergyseen inFelda’sEagle

  • HighBuy, 29Disember 2016,https://www.theedgesingapore.com/article/nosynergyseenfelda%E2%80%99seaglehighbuy,diaksespada25Mac2018;TheEdgeMarkets,RM1.13bpaperlossonEagleHigh investment, 6Mac2018,http://www.theedgemarkets.com/article/rm113bpaperlosseaglehighinvestment, diaksespada25Mac2018.

    42 RashilaRamli,TheMultipleRolesofRuralMalayWomenduring the1999Election:TheCaseofFeldaJ8,diterbitkandalamNew Politics inMalaysia, InstituteofSoutheastAsianStudies,Singapore, (2003);AbdulRahidMoten,The1999GeneralElections inMalaysia:TowardsaStableDemocracy?,AkademikaVol. 57,UKMPress, (2000),http://ejournal.ukm.my/akademika/article/view/2982,diaksespada23Mac2018.

    43 Malaysiakini,GovtadmitsRM2.7bil plunge inFeldareserves, 16Jun2010,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/134695,diaksespada13Mac2018.

    44 Malaysiakini,AhmadMaslan:FeldaspendsRM3.5bfromEPF loan, 30Jun2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/168528,diaksespada16Mac2018;Malaysiakini,RM6.5bilEPF loan toFeldaa ‘winwin’situation’, 1 Julai 2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/168558,diaksespada16Mac2018;Malaysiakini,Felda:Wecan repayEPFloan, 26Jun2011,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/168087,diaksespada16Mac2018.

    45 New StraitsTimes,EPF hassoldall its shares inFGV, 22Disember 2016,https://www.nst.com.my/news/2016/12/198772/epfhassoldallitssharesfgv,diaksespada18Mac2018.

    46 LeeBoonThongandTengkuShamsulBahrin,Felda’sFiftyYears:LandPioneers to Investors,KualaLumpur,Felda, (2006);KhorYuLeng, JohanSaravanamuttuandDeborahOgosin,HighCarbonStockConsultingStudy12:TheFeldaCaseStudy,Oxford,LMC InternationalLtd. (2015).

    47 LaporanTahunanFelda 2016.48 KhorYuLeng,TheFeldaquarrel and itsnational

    ramifications, diterbitkandalamPerspective IssueNo.51,Singapore, ISEASYusof Ishak Institute, 2017;Thepolitical tussleover Felda landschemes–UMNOstrengthen itsMalay rural fortress in13thgeneralelection,diterbitkandalamKajianMalaysiaVo.32Supp2,KhorYuLeng,Malaysia,PenerbitanUniversitiSainsMalaysia, 2014.

    49 Malaysiakini,NajibannouncesRM15,000 for everyFeldahousehold, 8May2012,

    https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/197265,diaksespada16Mac2018.

    50 6 insentif sejumlahRM1.6bilionyangdiumumkanuntukpenerokaFeldayangmenjual hasil tanimerekakepadaFeldadanmemilihuntukmenanamsemulapokoksawitmelaluiFeldaadalah:

    • Insentif khassebanyakRM5,000kepada94,956keluargapenerokaFeldauntukkebajikanmereka(kesemuanyaberjumlahRM474.78 juta);

    • Sebahagiandaripadapinjamanpenerokauntukmembeli sahamFGV akandilupuskandanpenerokapenerokayang telahmelangsaikanpinjamanmerekaakanmenerimaganjaran tunaisebanyakRM1,820 (kesemuanyaberjumlahRM128.1 juta);

    • Insentif sebanyakRM5,000untuksetiappenerokauntukmelangsaikanhutangpenanamansemula(kesemuanyaberjumlahRM519 juta);

    • PenubuhandanakhasuntukpenanamansemuladanpelupusanhutangbagimelunaskanhutangkospengendalianyangmelebihiRM40,000(keseluruhannyaberjumlahRM300 jutauntuktempoh5 tahunbermula2017hingga2021);

    • Penubuhangerankhaspenanamansemulapadakadar RM7,500sehektar bermula2017hingga2020 (kesemuanyaberjumlahRM166.6 jutaselama tempoh4 tahununtukkawasan24,280.31hektar); dan,

    • kelulusanuntukmembina lebihdaripadasaturumahdiatas tapak.

    TheStar Online,Najibannouncessix incentives forFeldasettlers, 23Julai 2017,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2017/07/23/najibannouncessixincentivesforfeldasettlers/ , diaksespada23Januari 2018.

    51 MalaysiaKini,RM1.6b incentives for settlers fundedmostlybyFelda, saysPutrajaya, 30Ogos2017,https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/393696#7IZRcbrXqqqCjUlD.99 ,diaksespada23Januari 2018.

    52 TheStar Online,Reward for Feldasettlers, 10Oktober2005,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2005/10/10/rewardforfeldasettlers/, diaksespada18Mac2018.

    53 TheStar Online,Bonus for Feldasettlers, 27November2004,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2004/11/27/bonusforfeldasettlers/, diaksespada16Mac2018.

    54 TheStar Online,Reward for Feldasettlers, 10Oktober2005,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2005/10/10/rewardforfeldasettlers/, diaksespada18Mac2018.

  • 55 TheStar Online,Settlers told to improvestatus, 13Disember 2005,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2005/12/13/settlerstoldtoimprovestatus/, diaksespada16Mac2018.

    56 UtusanOnline,112,635peneroka terimaduit rayaRM39.4 juta, 23September 2007,http://ww1.utusan.com.my/utusan/info.asp?y=2007&dt=0923&pub=Utusan_Malaysia&sec=Muka_Hadapan&pg=mh_04.htm,diaksespada18Mac2018.

    57 TheStar Online,Felda topayoutover RM146mil tosettlers, 23November 2007,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2007/11/23/feldatopayoutoverrm146miltosettlers/, diaksespada16Mac2018.

    58 TheStar Online,Rayawindfall for Feldasettlers, 7September 2008,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2008/09/07/rayawindfallforfeldasettlers/, diaksespada16Mac2018.

    59 TheStar Online,Feldasettlers to receiveproductivityincentivebonus, 21Oktober 2008,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2008/10/21/feldasettlerstoreceiveproductivityincentivebonus/,diaksespada18Mac2018.

    60 UtusanOnline,AdapenerokaFeldaperlekehduit raya,10September 2009,http://ww1.utusan.com.my/utusan/info.asp?y=2009&dt=0910&pub=Utusan_Malaysia&sec=Timur&pg=wt_07.htm,diaksespada18Mac2018.

    61 TheStar Online,NajibannouncesRM35O in ‘duit raya’for Feldasettlers, 14Ogos2010,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2010/08/14/najibannouncesrm350induitrayaforfeldasettlers/,diaksespada16Mac2018.

    62 TheStar Online,FeldapaysRM100.9mil in incentivebonus tosettlers, 25Disember 2010,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2010/12/25/feldapaysrm1009milinincentivebonustosettlers/,diaksespada18Mac2018.

    63 TheStar Online,PM:Feldasettlers togetRM42.6mil in‘duit raya’, 2Ogos2011,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2011/08/02/pmfeldasettlerstogetrm426milinduitraya/, diakses

    pada16Mac2018.64 TheStar Online,PMannounces incentivebonus for

    Feldasettlers, 23Disember 2011,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2011/12/23/pmannouncesincentivebonusforfeldasettlers/,diaksespada18Mac2018.

    65 TheStar Online,RM43mduit raya for Felda folk, 30Julai2012,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2012/07/30/rm43mduitrayaforfeldafolk/, diaksespada16Mac2018.

    66 TheStar Online, FeldapaysRM102.12mil inbonus toqualifiedsettlers, 14Januari 2013,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2013/01/14/feldapaysrm10212milinbonustoqualifiedsettlers/,diaksespada18Mac2018.

    67 TheStar Online,NajibannouncesRM32milHariRayabonus for Feldasettlers, 17Julai 2013,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2013/07/17/najibfeldarm32milrayabonus/, diaksespada16Mac2018.

    68 TheStar Online,Feldasettlers tocontinuegettingduitraya, 22Julai 2014,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/community/2014/07/22/feldasettlerstocontinuegettingduitraya/, diaksespada16Mac2018.

    69 TheStar Online,PMannouncesRM88.8mil payout forFeldasettlers, 8 Julai 2015,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2015/07/08/pmannouncesrm888milpayoutforfeldasettlers/,diaksespada16Mac2018.

    70 TheStar Online,Najibannounces ‘duit raya’ofRM49.52mil for Feldasettlers, 22Jun2016,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2016/06/22/najibannouncesduitrayaofrm49_52milforfeldasettlers/, diaksespada16Mac2018.

    71 Malaysiakini,PenerokaFeldadapatduit raya, kecuali…,10Julai 2017,https://m.malaysiakini.com/news/385222,diaksespada16Mac2018.

    72 TheStar Online,Najib:EachFeldasettler togetRM5,000cash incentive, 23Julai 2017,https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2017/07/23/feldasettlerstogetcashincentivescheme/, diaksespada16Mac2018.

    TheCenter toCombatCorruption andCronyismLamanWeb: www.c4center.orgEmel: [email protected]

    https://www.c4center.org/

    Laman Web:www.c4center.org�Emel:[email protected]