sindrom diare pada malnutrisi.pdf

8
139 TIlE A5IERI(AN JOURNAL OF CLINICAL NUTRITION Vo). 22, No. 2, F’ebrirry, 1969, pp. t3I-I46 I’rinled in U.S.A. Dehydration Syndrome in Malnourished Iranian Children MAHIN SADRE, M.D.,1 HAtsIts HEDAYAT, M.D.,1 MOHAMMAD GHARIIS, M.D., ZARRINDOKHT GHAVAM, PH.D.,1 AND GONZALO DoNoso, M.D. ONE-THIRD of time children acimitted to the pediatric wart!s in Teheran have been simown to be suffering from severe lmrotein-cl0rie tnalnu tn lion (1). However, malnutrition as such is rarely time cause of consultatioll or of admission, but rather an intercttrrent disease, as upper or lower respiratory infections in winter and diar- rheal t!isease in spring anti summer. It should 1)e pointed out, that nialnutrition is so common timat in many cases it is not eveti eimtered as a diagnosis in time pa- tient’s file. Diarrhea! disease in the malnourished child produces a dehydration syndrome that does not readily respond to the hydra- tion measures that are adequate in nor- mally nourished patients (2). Mortality rates in hospitalized malnourished chil- dren, many of them suffering from de- hydration, Imas been estimated at 30-50% in various parts of the world, including our country (1, 3-6). This clearly points out that dehydration in malnutrition is poorly understooti and that the therapeutic meas- mires employed are inadequate. It has been ortr aim to study dehydra- tion as it occurs in Iranian children suf- fering from the different forms of protein- calorie malnutrition, as a first step that will permit a niore rational approach to its treatment. In timis paper, we present the results of 1 Food an(I Nutrition Iimstitute of Iran, Teheran, Iran. 2 Professor of Pediatrics, Pahlavi Hospital, University of Teheran. Medical Nutritionist, World Healtim Organization. bioclietnical analyses of blood anti mtiscle of malnourisimed children suffering from delmydration because of diarrhea! disease at time moment of timeir atlmission and! prior to any parenteral treatment. Also, time con- dition of time discimarged patients, as seen 6 montims after timey were adimitted to the hospital is reporte(i. MATERIAI.S AND i’.IETHOI)S Clinical Material A total of 26 clmildren, 2-36 montims of age, was studied. They were chosen fronm timose con- sultimmg time outpatient clinic of Paimlavi Hospital (University of Teheran) during time summer of 1967. Time criteria for selecting our patients were: clinical evidence of dehydration (Sunken eyes, decreased elasticity of time skin, depressed fontanel, and dryness of mucous nmembranes); a imistory of acute diarrhea and vomiting in the premious 48 hr in a malnourisimed cimild; DO obvious Signs of pulmonary, ear, nose, and timroat infection, or of Specific iimfectious dis- eases: and no parenteral therapy received during time present episode. A diagnosis of kwaslmiorkor was given when timere was edema accompanied by imcpatomegaly aimd skin lesions. Time patient was classified as marasmic when edema was not preseimt aimd hepatonmegaly and skin lesions did not occur conconmitalmtiy. No attempt was nmade to standardize time various metimods of treatment enmployed by the responsible pimysicians. These treatnmemmts included (among others) use of: Dar- row’s solution, Ringer solution, a Ringer-lactate solution (1/6 isi) whole blood transfusions, plasnma, serunm aibunmin, ammd protein lmydroly- sates. by guest on November 18, 2012 ajcn.nutrition.org Downloaded from

Upload: rezkyjbt

Post on 18-Jul-2016

42 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SINDROM DIARE PADA MALNUTRISI.pdf

139

TIlE A5IERI(AN JOURNAL OF CLINICAL NUTRITION

Vo). 22, No. 2, F’ebrirry, 1969, pp. t3I-I46

I’rinled in U.S.A.

Dehydration Syndrome in Malnourished

Iranian Children

MAHIN SADRE, M.D.,1 HAtsIts HEDAYAT, M.D.,1 MOHAMMAD GHARIIS, M.D.,�

ZARRINDOKHT GHAVAM, PH.D.,1 AND GONZALO DoNoso, M.D.�

ONE-THIRD of time children acimitted to

the pediatric wart!s in Teheran have

been simown to be suffering from severe

lmrotein-c�l0rie tnalnu tn lion (1). However,malnutrition as such is rarely time cause of

consultatioll or of admission, but rather an

intercttrrent disease, as upper or lower

respiratory infections in winter and diar-

rheal t!isease in spring anti summer. It

should 1)e pointed out, that nialnutrition

is so common timat in many cases it is not

eveti eimtered as a diagnosis in time pa-

tient’s file.

Diarrhea! disease in the malnourished

child produces a dehydration syndrome

that does not readily respond to the hydra-

tion measures that are adequate in nor-

mally nourished patients (2). Mortality

rates in hospitalized malnourished chil-

dren, many of them suffering from de-

hydration, Imas been estimated at 30-50%

in various parts of the world, including our

country (1, 3-6). This clearly points out

that dehydration in malnutrition is poorly

understooti and that the therapeutic meas-

mires employed are inadequate.

It has been ortr aim to study dehydra-

tion as it occurs in Iranian children suf-

fering from the different forms of protein-

calorie malnutrition, as a first step that

will permit a niore rational approach to its

treatment.

In timis paper, we present the results of

1 Food an(I Nutrition Iimstitute of Iran, Teheran,

Iran. 2 Professor of Pediatrics, Pahlavi Hospital,

University of Teheran. � Medical Nutritionist,World Healtim Organization.

bioclietnical analyses of blood anti mtiscle

of malnourisimed children suffering from

delmydration because of diarrhea! disease at

time moment of timeir atlmission and! prior

to any parenteral treatment. Also, time con-

dition of time discimarged patients, as seen

6 montims after timey were adimitted to the

hospital is reporte(i.

MATERIAI.S AND i’.IETHOI)S

Clinical Material

A total of 26 clmildren, 2-36 montims of age,

was studied. They were chosen fronm timose con-

sultimmg time outpatient clinic of Paimlavi Hospital

(University of Teheran) during time summer of

1967. Time criteria for selecting our patients

were: clinical evidence of dehydration (Sunken

eyes, decreased elasticity of time skin, depressed

fontanel, and dryness of mucous nmembranes);

a imistory of acute diarrhea and vomiting in the

premious 48 hr in a malnourisimed cimild; DO

obvious Signs of pulmonary, ear, nose, and

timroat infection, or of Specific iimfectious dis-

eases: and no parenteral therapy received during

time present episode. A diagnosis of kwaslmiorkor

was given when timere was edema accompanied

by imcpatomegaly aimd skin lesions. Time patient

was classified as marasmic when edema was not

preseimt aimd hepatonmegaly and skin lesions did

not occur conconmitalmtiy. No attempt was nmade

to standardize time various metimods of treatment

enmployed by the responsible pimysicians. These

treatnmemmts included (among others) use of: Dar-

row’s solution, Ringer solution, a Ringer-lactate

solution (1/6 isi) whole blood transfusions,

plasnma, serunm aibunmin, ammd protein lmydroly-

sates.

by guest on Novem

ber 18, 2012ajcn.nutrition.org

Dow

nloaded from

Page 2: SINDROM DIARE PADA MALNUTRISI.pdf

140

TABLE I

Son’e clinical characteristics in 26 malnourished patients suffering from dehydrati im

Age, -

months CX

Dehy- Pallor Skindration lesions

Per-\Vt, centagekg ideal

wt

2.4’ 48

3.5 44

2.8 42

5.5 50

4.0 35

4.5 47

Case

num-ber

2

34

a

6

7

8I)

10

11

12

13

14

15

it)

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

Name

ASA

ZB

ZE

sPAMA

RH

AB

AG

AH

AMI

MP

MK

KB

A4’AI()

FS

AN

MSA

MSA

AT

MO

ASO

FA

AK

i)A

MB

2

7

4

18

18

11

6

12

27

8

9

4

2

14

2

36

10

17

6

16

24

11

11

11

24

10

M

F

FF

M

F

M

M

F

M

F

F

F

M

F

M

F

F

F

M

M

F

F

M

M,

M

4-4

3.3

6.0

39

5-9

2.9

1.9

6.0

2.6

3-4

4.5

5.5

3-4

5.6

4.0

59

34

46

46

67

46

36

58

51

23

49

50

46

52

32

++

++

+++++

+++

+

++++

+

+++

+++++

+

+++++++++

++++++

+++

+++++++

+++

Hepa-tome-

galy

++

++

++

+

+++

++

+

+

+++

+++

+++++

++

+++

+++++++

++

+

+++

+++++

++

++

++++

+++

++

++

+++

+++

+++

++

++

++

++

+++

+

++

+++

+++

+++�

Edema, Edema,local general

+

+

- ++

+ -

- +++

+ -

++ -

+ -

+ -

- +++

- +++

- +++ -

+ -

Dis-

Other 2

days

No

No 9

No 26

No

No

Skin in- 16

fection

No I

No

Kerato- 34

mnalacia�

No

J aundice�

No 7

No

Otitis 14

�miedia

No 13

No 21

No

No

No 13

No 12

Eye in-

fection

No 8

No 11

12

No 7

No

Deathafter

1 day

1 day

8 hr

5 days

9 days

4 days

3 hr

9 days

3 days

1 day

3 days

2 days

5.9 59

4.7 50

5.8, 61

4.0� 32

3.8 41

Sadre et al.

Chemical Determinations

Blood samples and muscle biopsies were ob-

tained withmin 1 hr of admission and prior to any

timerapy. Blood was withdrawn from the jugular

or femoral vein and time following determina-

tions were carried out: Hematocrit and hemo-

globin (7), sodium and potassium (by flame

photometry in an EEL flame photometer),

calcium (8), cimloride (9), bicarbonate (10), phos-

phorus (11), total keto acids (12), total serum

proteins, and albumin (13). The biopsies (150-

500 mg) were obtained surgically from the del-

toid muscle. The samples were dried at 100 C

and timen extracted with light petroleum ether

in a micro-Soxhiet. The dry, defatted tissue was

ashed in a platinum dish at 450 C, the ashes were

taken up in a small quantity of nitric acid and

made up to a known volume. Sodium and po-

tassium were determined in the ash liquor by

flame pimotometry.

RESULTS

Table i shows the age, sex, weight, per-

centage idea! weight (14), and other clini-

cal characteristics of our patients on ad-

mission. In Table ii their blood values for

hemoglobin, hematocrit, sodium, potas-

sium, calcium, phosphorus, total keto acids

(as pyruvic), chloride, bicarbonate, total

serum proteins, and albumin are given.

Time sodium and potassium content

by guest on Novem

ber 18, 2012ajcn.nutrition.org

Dow

nloaded from

Page 3: SINDROM DIARE PADA MALNUTRISI.pdf

Death Hb, g/Type within Hct, % 100 ml

4 days

Calcium, Chloride,niEq/ mEq/

liter liter

Bicar-bonate,mEq/liter

13.3

6.0

17.0

0.0

6.0

6.0

17.0

18.0

42.0

2.0

18.1

9.7

12.9

64

80

68

100

100

82

82

96

84.0

MM

M

MMM

MM

M

MMM

KK

KK

KKK

KKKKKK

K

+

+

+

++

+

+

+

+

CaseNumber

2

3

5

8

10

12

13

15

17

21

23

Avg

SD

SEM

4

6

7

9

11

14

16

18

19

20

22

24

25

26Avg

SD

SEM

P

Sodium,mEq/

liter

146

136

136

146

156

154

136

152

152

158

125

136

144.4

10.4

3.0

122

122

130

154

138

144

144

158

156

133

122

139

144

136

138.7

12.2

3.3

1 .28

N.S.

13.90 11.1

34

35

46

47

33

50

3217

27

32

36

38

35-5

9.1

2.6

21

21

31

23

31

28

38

23

31

32

25

42

41

29.8

7.2

2.0

1 .75

N.S.a

Potas-sium,

mEq/liter

3.2

3.8

2.713.2

3.7

5.6

3.5

6.0

6.0

4.6

2.5

4.2

4.9

2.9

0.83

3.8

5.8

4-9

3.2

3.7

3.8

4-3

2.3

2.6

3-4

4. 1

2.9

2.6

2.0

3-5

0.96

0.25

2.07

0.05

8.4

8.2

7.5

14.0

9.0

13.5

8.9

5.2

9.4

10.6

11.0

12.0

9.8

2.5

0.73

5.6

5.5

8.1

6.6

7.8

9.1

11.0

8.1

9-4

9.0

7.712.2

11.5

8.6

2.1

0.58

1 .28

N.S.

5.6

6.6

6.6

5.8

1 .6

3.6

2.8

3.0

3.0

7.0

5.0

5.0

4.6

1 .8

0.51

5-9

3.6

4-9

11.9

4-9

3.0

5.0

8.0

9.2

2.5

1.7

5.0

5.0

6.7

4.8

2.2

0.58

0.25

N.S.

Phos-phorus,mg/tOO

ml

4.7

4.5

2.4

3.1

2.2

3-5

8.6

8.5

6.8

5.7

5.4

5.7

5.1

2. 1

0.61

2.2

4-7

4.0

3.2

6.2

5.3

5.6

3.2

5.1

4.6

1.9

1.4

5. 1

3-4

4.0

1.5

0.39

1.52

N.S.

Total Total Serumketo serum albu-

acids, proteinj mm,mliq/ g/iOO g/l0O

liter ml ml

6.4 4.0

0.95 6.9 3.5

0.33 6.6 3.4

0.72 6.6

0.17 4.8 2.7

0.28 6.6 4.5

0.46 7.2 3.8

0.16 6.3 3.3

0.46 7.5 3.80.41 7.2 3.8

0.34 6.6 1 3�4

0.46 6.6 3.4

0.44 6.6 3.6

0.23 0.67 0.46

0.07 0.19 0.14

0.22 3.0 1

0.21 4.7 2.0

1.18 4.20.32 4.8

0.34 3.6 1.2

0.36 4.8 1.6

0.69 4.8 1.8

0.36 4.6 2.4

0.24 3.9 1.8

0.54 I 4�5 2.9

0.70 3.9 1.8

4.5 2.0

4.2 1.5

0.32 3.6 , 1.8

0.46 4.2 1.9

0.26 0.55 0.46

0.10 0.15 0.12

0.12 10.6 9.6

N.S. 0.001 0.001

4.9054

84

76

90

102

118

81

101

102

95

90

91. 1

16.5

4.98

0.96

N.S.

3.2

4.0

6.0

27.0

6.0

6.0

12.0

10.0

16.0

6.0

23.0

7.7

15.5

18.0

13.1

12.2

4.8

1.3

0. 19

N.S.

Dehydration in Malnourished Children

TABLE II

Blood levels in 12 marasmic- and 14 kwashiorkor-dehydrated children

a N.S. = not significant.

141

(mEq/100 g of defatted, dry tissue) in

muscle biopsies, five from edematous and

five from nonedematous patients, is shown

in Table iii.

Table iv simows the condition of the dis-

cimarged patients, as recorded from a home

visit made 6 months after they were ad-

mmmitteti to time hospital. The weights on dis-

cimarge anti at time imoimme visit are also given.

DISCUSSION

Dehydration in the malnourished pa-

tient can be due to a parenteral disease,

sucim as bronclmopneumonia, but it is nmuch

by guest on Novem

ber 18, 2012ajcn.nutrition.org

Dow

nloaded from

Page 4: SINDROM DIARE PADA MALNUTRISI.pdf

19

22

27

43

26

27.4

22

24

42

28

44

32.0

24.8

25.4

23.0

28.6

20.6

24.4

18.0

27.0

6.5

31.3

14.5

19.4

Sadre et a!.142

TABLE lit

Sodiutim aimd potassium iim muscle biopsies of

10 dehydrated immalmmourished children,

nmEq 100 g dry, fat-free

Patient number Sodium Potassium

Marasmus

3

5

12

13

17

Mean

Kwashiorkor

4

6

14

16

18

Meamm

TABLE IV

Weight oim adnmission, discharge and after 6

nmonths imm six dehydrated nmaltmourished

children

Patient

number

Wt on admissionkVt on discharge\Vt after 6 months

of aelmission

kg�I

Per-centagel kg

ideal �vt�

Per-centageideal svt

kgPer-

centageideal wt

3 2.8 44 3.0 47 Died Died

6 4.5 47 5.4 56 6.0 54

9 6.0 46 6.2 47 6.4 45

16 3.4 23 4.4 30 4.5 29

19 3.4 46 3.5 47 Died Died

20 5.7 52 7.0 64 Died Died

more comimmon as a coimsequence of diar-

rheal disease. Time reason dehydration pre-

sents such an unfavorable prognosis and is

so difficult to correct is not clearly under-

stood1, but time following factors have been

thought to be responsible: abnormal dis-

tribution of water in the body compart-

ments (2, 15. 16); the larger surface area

per unit of body weight; alteration in the

biocimemical processes that supply energy

(17); dlepletion in magnesium and potas-

sium (18); (!isutrbances in time excretion of

water and solutes by the kidney (19, 20);

anti time like.

There is some disagreement on the

merits of hydration in time treatment of

malnourished patients. Some authors (21)

claim considerable success with the use of

a multielectrolyte hypotonic solution in

hyper- or hyponatremic patients. Otimers

(22) warn of the high risks involved in us-

ing hydration therapy in hyponatremic

malnourished patients. It is possible that

some of the discrepancies are due to the

predominance of kwashiorkor or marasmic

patients in the material studied. In this

way, marasmus, with early weaning to a

bacteriologically contaminated diet of poor

nutritional value, is by far the predomi-

nant type in subtropical countries (23-26).

On the other hand, kwashiorkor, with late

weaning to a diet very low in protein con-

tent, seems to be more common in the less

urbanized areas of tropical Africa and

America (27, 28). The differences that

have been reported to exist between the

two extremes of the protein-calorie mal-

nutrition spectrum such as liver damage,

edema, hypoalbuminemia, and anemia

could be thought to have some influence on

the biochemical picture of dehydration in

the malnourished child. However, in our

material, the type of malnutrition does

not have any bearing on the prognosis

(Table i). This observation is in agreement

with the findings of the Mexican authors

(29), who simply classify malnutrition ac-

cording to the percentage of ideal weight.

The age of the child and other clinical

characteristics, with the notable exception

of drowsiness, did not show a clear-cut

relationship with the outcome (Table i).

Drowsiness was present in seven of time

nine cases that died within 4 days of ad-

mission. A similar finding has been re-

ported by South African workers (30) and

by Chilean authors (31), who term dehy-

dration with drowsiness as “toxicosis” and

consider it to be a very bad prognosis.

Seventeen of the 26 patients studied were

by guest on Novem

ber 18, 2012ajcn.nutrition.org

Dow

nloaded from

Page 5: SINDROM DIARE PADA MALNUTRISI.pdf

0

-0-0

0

0

45

,40U‘I,

� 35

>‘L

O 30

a25

a0

20C)

0

9 15

N

10

5

0

0

-�1

.

.

.

.

.

.

Na KJ

Kwashiorkor

Nal K

Marasmus

Na K

Normal

Dehydration in Malnourisimed Children 143

1 year of age or younger. This points oimce

nmore to time predominance of malignant

immaimmutrition in time infant over that in time

prescimool child in lime urban areas of thedeveloping countries.

Time only biochemical sign consistent

with time type of malnutrition was hypo-

aibuminemia, whicim was present in all the

patients suffering from kwashiorkor (Table

it). Hematocrit and hemoglobin levels

were Imiglmer in time marasmic patients, but

time difference was not statistically signifi-

cant. Near norlnal values have been re-

ported for albunmin and lmemoglobin in the

nmarasmic chiltl (32, 33), whereas anemia

and hypoalbuminemia are a constant find-

ilmg imm kwasimiorkor (34). Severe anemia,

with imemoglobin levels of less than 7 g/

100 ml, was present in four of our patients,

but diti not seem to play any role in their

chances for survival (Tables i and mm). Hy-

pernatremia, with figures over 152 mEq/

liter, was present in six cases and hypo-

natremia, with values under 130 mEq/

liter was seen in four patients. Alterations

in the sodium content of serum, especially

ilyponatremia, have been reported as a

sign of bad prognosis (22, 35). In our

series, imowever, time children that presented

abnornmal sodium values did no worse than

timose with sodium levels witimin the

imormal range. Hypernatremia was not con-

sistently associated with increased hemato-

crit values, such as would suggest Imypo-

voleimmia, witim time possible exception of

case 10 (Table ii).

Patients suffering from kwashiorkor had

lower potassium levels, in both serum and

muscle, than marasmic patients (Tables

ii and III). However, time difference was

only significant for serum, possibly because

of time low number of muscle biopsies.

Hypopotassemia was present in five kwa-

simiorkor cases but in only two marasmic

cimildren, and hyperpotassemia was found

imm four marasmic patients. The very high

potassium content (13.5 mEq/iiter) in pa-

tient 5 occurret! together with a very low

Fic. 1. Sodium ammd potassium in muscle of de-

hydrated malnourished children. Comparison with

nornmal values (36).

chloride value and imo deternminable bi-

carbonate. The patient died a few imours

after admission. Such imigh levels of potas-

sium imave been recorded in agonic mal-

imourishied patients by otimer autimors (2).

No consistent relation could be demon-

strated between sodium ammd potassium

levels in time serum with those in time

muscle. Time extent of time potassium de-

pietion in muscle cannot be judgeti from

time level of timis element in time serum. The

muscle biopsies simoweti a higher content

of sodiumlm anti lower potassititmm than nor-

nmal muscle. Time pattertm itm timese two

electrolytes is altereti, probably more in

kwasimiorkor tlman in tmmarasmus, as can be

seen frotmm Fig. 1 in wimich outr results are

compared with timose given by Dubois et

al. (36) for normal cimildren. Timese authors

found no marked loss of potassium in the

nmuscle of dehydrateti patietmts witim nor-

mal nutritioimal status.

It is not clear to us if time clmammges founti

in the muscle electrolytes are brougimt

about by deimydration, or wimetimer delmy-

by guest on Novem

ber 18, 2012ajcn.nutrition.org

Dow

nloaded from

Page 6: SINDROM DIARE PADA MALNUTRISI.pdf

144 Sadre et a!.

dration simply aggravates a preexisting

abtmormaiit�. Similar alterations as re-

ported here imave been found in marasmic

children sumfferi ng from dehydration (37).

Also. decreased concentration of potassium

aimtI an increase in sodhum have been

simowtm to exist in patieimts suffering from

U mmcommlpl i ca ted kwashiorkor (38).

Disturbances in time mechanisms that

supply energy to time cell imave been re-

porteti imm immalmmutrition (17). These could

be responsible for aim inadequate perform-

ance jim time ostimotic work that keeps p0-

tassiunm inside andi time sotiium outside time

cell, explainimmg thereby time changes found

in time nmuscle of our patients.

Some of time children studied had very

low calcenmia, but mmone showed evidence of

tetanv. It is possible timat acidosis, which

increases time percentage of ionic calcium,

can account for lack of this sign.

Time acid-base composition of time serum

in many of otmr patients showeti a con-

siderable gap between the sum of the

anions and the cations. It appeared pos-

sible that timis gap could be related, at

least imm part, to atm increase in keto acids.

However, time level in timese compounds did

mmot differ significantly from that found in

a series of eigimt normmmal children of com-

parable age, i.e., 0.45 ± 0.07 versus 0.32 ±

0.02 mEq total keto acids (as pyruvic) per

liter. Hypocimloremia with very low bi-

cari)onate levels and lmigh amounts of un-

deterimmined anions was frequent in our

material. Acidosis with somewimat similar

cimaracteristics may be encountered in pro-

found metabolic alterations sucim as the

diial)etic coma.

Time cimloride level in time serum was a

sign of some progmmostic value in our pa-

tients. Timus, all eigimt of the cimildren that

imad cimlorenmias of 95 mEq/liter or higher

sui-vivet!, wimereas all timree that presented

figures of less than 70 d!ied!. Bicarbonate

levels ms-ere associated with prognosis more

or less in time sanme way: seven of the eight

patieimts ms-itim figures above 17 mEq/liter

surviveti, and all timree that showed the

lowest levels died.

Time results shown in Table mmclearly in-

dicate that the biochemical picture in de-

imydration in time malnourished child can

vary considerably from patient to patient.

The tieath rate in our series was 46%. It

would seem timat to obtain better survival

rates, a therapy directed to improve the

metabolic disturbance found in each in-

tiividual case should be considered. This

means increasing the existent laboratory

and nursing facilities that are far from

adequate. From time economic point of

view timis is justifiable if a larger number

of patients can be saved timan at present

whim this directed therapy, a probable but

still unproven proposition.

In our series, each child that is dis-

chargeti alive represents an average of 17

patient-days. At a cost of $5/patient-day,

each success represents $85. The doubtful

value of timese “successes” can be seen from

time figures shown in Table iv. Out of six

patients that were discharged from theimospitai and could be located, three had

died before 6 months. The nutritional con-

dition of those found to be alive 6 months

after admission, as jut!ged from their per-

centage of ideal weight, was nearly as bat!

as on (iiscimarge. Timeir chances of survival

into adulthood would appear to be rather

small and even if they did survive their

pimysical and intellectual development

could be considerably impaired (39).

Because of the imigh cost of hospitaliza-

tion and time higim demand for beds, the

deimydrate(I malnourisimed patient is dis-

cimargeti as soon as imis acute episode is over,

witim practically no recovery in his nu-

tritional state (Tables m and iv). A cimance

for inmproving it should be provided at

Centers for Nutritional Rehabilitation

(40), wimere costs can be mutch lower timan

in time hospital.

It appears to us that without proper

facilities for the treatment of dehytiration,

and witimout a definite improvement in time

by guest on Novem

ber 18, 2012ajcn.nutrition.org

Dow

nloaded from

Page 7: SINDROM DIARE PADA MALNUTRISI.pdf

Dehydration in Malnourished Children 145

nutritional status of time patient before he

is returned to his environment, the effi-

ciency of Imospitalizing and treating the

dehydrated malnourished child, measured

in money spent for each full recovery, will

continue to be very low.

SUMMARY

A study was made on some of the clinical

and biochemical characteristics of dehydra-

tion consecutive to diarrheal disease as it

occurred in 26 malnourished Iranian chil-

tlren, 2-36 montims of age.

No significant difference could be shown

to exist between the blood levels of hemo-

giobin, sodium, calcium, phosphorus, chlo-

ritie, bicarbonate and total keto acids

exhibited by the marasmic (12) and kwa-

shiorkor (14) patients. Significantly, higher

total serum proteins, albumin and potas-

sium were found in the marasmic children.

Muscle biopsies in malnourished pa-

tients of the kwashiorkor (5) and marasmic

(5) type revealed a higlmer content of

sodium and a lower content of potassium

than reported in tue literature for the

nmuscle in normal children.

Clinically, the only sign consistent with

bad prognosis was drowsiness. Biochemi-

cally, low bicarbonate and low chloride

levels were associated with a fatal out-

come.

The intrahospital immortality was about

50%. Of the patients discharged alive that

could be traced 6 montims after leaving the

lmospital, three had died and the other

tlmree did not show any improvement in

timeir nutritional condition. These facts

point to time poor economic efficiency of

treating time dehydrateci malnourisimedl pa-

tients under present conditions.

We gratefully ackmlowlcdge the help received

from Dr. R. Moazanmi and Dr. J. Salamati for the

facilities offered for tmospitalization and care of the

p2mticnts. Our thanks also go to the staff of theSurgical Ward No. 1, Pahlavi Hospital, especially to

I)ms. M. Mir, A. Mir and H. Ahrari for performing

the muscle biopsies. We thank Misses M. Kamker,

A. Nevisi, A. YouSefi, ammd P. Hamedi, and Mr. S. A.

Zeidi for help in the chemical determinations.

REFERENCES

1. HEDAYAT, H., M. GHARIB AND M. SADRE. Protein-

calorie malnutrition in lmospitalizcd Iraniamm

children. I. Trop. Pediat. To be published.

2. METCOFF, J., S. FRENK, G. GORDILLO, F. GOMEZ,R. RAMOS-GALVAN, J. CRAvI0T0, C. A. JANEWAY

AND J. L. GAMBLE. Intracellular composition

amid honmeostatic mechanisms in severe chronic

infan tile malnutrition. IV. Development and re-pair of the biocimemnical lesions. Pediatrics 20:

317, 1967.

3. MENECHELLO, J., J. ROSSELOT, C. AGUILO, F.MONCKEBERG, 0. UNDURRAGA AND M. FERREIRO.

Infantile diarrlmea and dehydration: ambulatory

treatment in a hydration center. Ado. Pediat. 9:

183, 1960.

4. GOMEZ, F., R. RAMOS-GALVAN, S. FRENK, J.CR&vioTo, R. CHAVEZ AND J. VASQUEZ. Mortality

in secommd and third degree malnutrition. I.Ti-op. Pediat. 2: 77, 1936.

5. AGREN, G., G. ALMGARD, 0. MELLANDER AND B.VAEILQUIST. Children Nutritioml Unit-an Ethio-

pian Swedish Project in the Field of Health.

Ethiopian Med. J. 3: 5, 1966.

6. GORDILLO, G. El sindrome de deshidratacion en

el nino desnutrido. Rev. 5Iex. Pediat. 25: 257,

1936.

7. Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition forNational Defense. Manual for Nutrition Surveys

(2nd ed). Washington D. C.: U.S. Govt. Printing

Office, 1963.

8. DIEHL, H., AND J. L. ELLINGBOE. Indicator for

titration of calcium in presence of magnesium

witlm disodium ethylenediaminetetraacetate.

Anal. Chem. 28: 882, 1956.

9. WHITEHoRN, J. C. A system for blood analysis.Supplememmt II. Simplified methods for the de-

ternmination of chloride in blood or plasma. J.Biol. Chein. 45: 449, 1921.

tO. O’BRIEN, D., AND F. A. Innorr. Laboratory Man-

ual of Pediatric Micro and Ultramicro Biochem-

ical Techniques (3rd ed). New York: Harper &

Row, 1962, p. 47.

11. FISKE, C. H., AND Y. SUBBAROW. The colon-

metric determninatiomm of phosphorus. 1. Biol.

C/,e,,i. 66: 375, 1923.

12. KOEI’SELL, H. J., AND E. S. SHARPE. Microdeter-

mination of pyruvic and aipha-ketoglutanic

acids. Arch. Bioc/iem. Biophys. 39: 443, 1932.

13. WO0T0N, I. D. P. Microanalysis in Medical Bio-

chemistry. London: Churchill, 1964.

14. STUART, H. C., AND S. S. STEVENSON. Percentiles

for weight and length, Harvard School of Public

Health. iii: Textbook of Pediatrics, edite(1 by

W. E. Nelson. Philadelpimia: Saunders, 1964.

15. BRINKMAN, G. L., M. D. BOWIE, B. FRmms-HAN5EN

AND j. D. L. HANSEN. Body water conmposition in

by guest on Novem

ber 18, 2012ajcn.nutrition.org

Dow

nloaded from

Page 8: SINDROM DIARE PADA MALNUTRISI.pdf

Sadre et a!.146

kwashiorkor before and after loss of edema.

Pediatrics 36: 94, 1965.

16. KERPEL-FRONIUS, E. The volume and composi-tion of the body fluid compartments in severeinfantile malnutrition. J. Pediat. 56: 826, 1960.

17. METCOFF, J., S. FRENK, T. YOSHIDA, R. TomutEsPINF.1o, E. KAISER AND J. D. L. HANSEN. Cell

composition and metabolism in kwashiorkor(severe protein-calorie malnutrition in children).Anal. Rev. Med. 45: 365, 1966.

18. MONTGOMERY, R. D. Magnesium balance studiesin marasnmic kwashiorkor. J. Pediat. 59: 119,

1961.

19. ALLEYNE, G. A. 0. The effect of severe proteincalorie malnutrition on the renal function ofJamaican children. Pediatrics 39: 400, 1967.

20. GoiwmLLo, G., R. A. SoTo, J. METCOFF, E. LoPEz

AND L. G. ANTILLON. Intracellular composition

ammd homeostatic mechanisms in severe chronicmalnutrition. III. Renal adjustments. Pediatrics

20: 303, 1967.

21. MENEGHELLO, J., C. AcumLo, F. MONCKEBERG, E.

CERu-r-rm, H. SORIANO, S. RuBmo AND E. FERNANDEZ.

Analisis de 244 lactantes con deshiratacion agudagrave, con especial referencia a su tratamientocon una solucion maltielectrolitica, Pediatria,

Santiago 5: 431, 1962.

22. SMITH, R. Hyponatremia in infantile malnutri-

tion. Lancet 1: 771, 1963.

23. DoNoso, G., AND F. MONCKEBERG. Desnutricion

infantil. Consideraciones generales y epidemio-logia. Rev. Chilena Pediat. 36: 301, 1965.

24. MCLAREN, D. S. A fresh look at protein-calorie

mnainutnition. Lancet 2: 485, 1966.

25. WRAY, J. D. Kwashiorkor and marasmus in

Turkey. In: Meeting protein needs of infants

and children. Nati. Acad. Sci.-Natl. Res. Coun-

cil Publ. 843, Washington, D. C., 1961.

26. GRAHAM, G. G., AND E. MORALES. Studies in

infantile malnutrition. 1. Nature of the problem

in Peru. 1. .\‘utr. 79: 479, 1963.

27. JELLIFFE, D. B. Protein-calorie malnutrition in

tropical pre-school children. J. Pediat. 54: 227,

1959.28. PATWARDHAN, V. N. Deficiency diseases. Proc.

Sixth Intern. Congr. Nutr. Edinburgh: Living-

stone, 1963.

29. GOMEZ, F., R. RAMOS-GALVAN, J. CRAVIOTO AND

F. FRENK. Malnutrition in infancy and child-

hood, with special reference to kwashiorkor.

Adv. Pediat. 7: 131, 1955.

30. KAHN, E. Prognostic criteria of severe protein-

calorie malnutrition. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 7: 161,

1959.31. SCROGGIE, A., AND H. GARCES. La diarrea aguda

del lactante mirada desde el punto de vista cli-

nico. Rev. Chilena Pediat. 24: 219, 1963.

32. DoNoso, G., 0. BRUNSER AND F. MONCKEBERG.

Metabolismn of serum albumin in marasmic in-

fants. J. Pediat. 67: 306, 1965.

33. MONCKEBERG, F. J. VILDOSOLA, M. FIGUEROA, S.

OXMAN AND J. MENEGHELLO. Hematological dis-turbances in infantile malnutrition. Values for

copper, iron, panaphenylene diamine oxidase

and iron binding capacity in serum. Am. 1.

Gun. Nutr. 11: 525, 1962.34. GARROW, J. S. “Kwashiorkor” and “marasmus”

in Jamaican infants. Arch. Latinoam. Nutr. 16:146, 1966.

35. GARROW, J. S., AND M. C. PIKE. The short term

prognosis of severe primary infantile malnutri-

tion. Brit. J. Nutr. 21: 155, 1967.

36. DuBoms, J., J. COLARD AND H. L. Vis. Muscle

electrolyte composition determined by neutron

activation. A preliminary study of dehydration

in infants. J. Nuci. Med. 7: 827, 1966.

37. MONCKEBERG, F., 0. GASC AND R. ARTIGAS. Estudio

de los electroiitos intracelulares por medio de la

biopsia muscular en el desnutrido. Pediatria,

Santiago 2: 114, 1959.

38. FRENK, S., J. METCOFF, F. GOMEZ, R. RAMOS-

GALVIN, J. CRAVIOTO AND I. ANToNowmcz. In-

tracellular composition and homeostatic mecha-

nisms in severe chronic infantile malnutrition.

II. Composition of tissues. Pediatrics 20: 105,

1957.

39. CRAvIOTO, J. Malnutrition and behavioral de-

velopment in the pre-school child. Pre-school

child malnutrition, primary deterrent to human

progress. Natl. Acad. Sci.-Natl. Res. Council

Pubi. 1282, Washington, D. C., 1966.

40. BENGOA, J. M. Nutritional rehabilitation centers.

I. Trop. Pediat. In press.

by guest on Novem

ber 18, 2012ajcn.nutrition.org

Dow

nloaded from